VaultNetwork.netVault Network Boards
Author Topic: OMG thanes need love! [Locked]
GrendelRex  1 star
Posts: 156
Registered: 2004-2-29 09:00:36
StanleyM84 posted:

Yesterday, I was debuffed by a cabby and nuked sorc... Sorc crit me for 918 with MoM5, I nuked him back for 239 (-177). Sorc being a primary CC class, I think thane's spell damage, considering they have NO cc, should be a bit better.



So you're reasoning as to why a Thane needs better ranged dps is because a Sorc hits you hard when you're debuffed 50%(probably) by his Cabby partner?


StanleyM84 posted:

A thane should be able to melee with the best and ranged DPS with the best.



Asking for much?
andynNIN  1 star
Posts: 62
Registered: 2004-9-27 21:50:26
StanleyM84 posted:

Yesterday, I was debuffed by a cabby and nuked sorc... Sorc crit me for 918 with MoM5, I nuked him back for 239 (-177). Sorc being a primary CC class, I think thane's spell damage, considering they have NO cc, should be a bit better.



maybe you need a template and a lesson on ras?

i would log if i nuked a caster for less that 400 a nuke on my rr12 smiter.

 

-----signature-----
-andyn-
12l3 smiter, lvl85 priest...
----MCFC----
phise 'I don't know who is laying down more punishment, the Catholic Church, Man City, or Andyn in this thread'
b0xy  2 stars
Posts: 314
Registered: 2009-3-21 20:06:56
andynNIN posted:

StanleyM84 posted:

Yesterday, I was debuffed by a cabby and nuked sorc... Sorc crit me for 918 with MoM5, I nuked him back for 239 (-177). Sorc being a primary CC class, I think thane's spell damage, considering they have NO cc, should be a bit better.



maybe you need a template and a lesson on ras?

i would log if i nuked a caster for less that 400 a nuke on my rr12 smiter.



Yeah.

Wait what?

 

-----signature-----
[3:23:33 PM] Bogle: i like playing wow i dont have to worry about positioning or if theres people on me or casting any other spell other than a heal
StanleyM84  1 star
Posts: 109
Registered: 2009-8-17 13:37:49
Yes I mentioned I was debuffed, but that damage differential from a high utility toon, sorc, to a non-utility toon, thane, is obscene. Sorcs have an insane amount of toys and to be able to assit a debuff train with that type of result is impressive. I think thanes without all that utility should have a chance at similar numbers somehow. Right now its is truely impossible.


List caster's defensive abilitys are under-rated. Things like Stun, Root, casted ranged snare, mez and nearsight are truely devistating. Thane gets none of these. Playing a class without any of those, the focus needs to be on pure DPS. Thane is not exactly a "dps" class as it is.


So either more ranged dps or some cc/defensive toys are warranted. They just dont have the utility or the dps right now, something class defining is missing.


Andynin,

he had pretty nice resists and I didnt have time to get off a 3second cast debuff. 239 (-177) is not good but its all that a 187delve dd without acuity buff can attain on a high resist target. It looks like he had 25+5+24=52% energy resist, high for alb unless they had a buffbot spec cleric. Or bot in group for resists before run.


rr8|5 with 10spell damage, 10pierce, MoM5, Acuity5, WP4 at the moment for spell stuffs.

 

-----signature-----
Gaven rr11|9 Warrior
Gavster rr10 Healer, Gavenjr rr8 sm, Gavena rr7 valk, Gaviir rr7 vamp
rr6 and under: Gavani, Gavain, Gmaul, Gavensrm
Currently playing - Anicethane - r9l5 Thane
GrendelRex  1 star
Posts: 156
Registered: 2004-2-29 09:00:36
StanleyM84 posted:

Yes I mentioned I was debuffed, but that damage differential from a high utility toon, sorc, to a non-utility toon, thane, is obscene. Sorcs have an insane amount of toys and to be able to assit a debuff train with that type of result is impressive. I think thanes without all that utility should have a chance at similar numbers somehow. Right now its is truely impossible.



So you really can't see the problem that might arise with a chain wearing, shield carrying melee class doing the kind of ranged damage a Sorc does when a Cabby debuffs for them?
PasswordLLOTH  3 stars
Title: i can haz title
Posts: 517
Registered: 2007-6-13 17:45:05
b0xy posted:

andynNIN posted:

StanleyM84 posted:

Yesterday, I was debuffed by a cabby and nuked sorc... Sorc crit me for 918 with MoM5, I nuked him back for 239 (-177). Sorc being a primary CC class, I think thane's spell damage, considering they have NO cc, should be a bit better.



maybe you need a template and a lesson on ras?

i would log if i nuked a caster for less that 400 a nuke on my rr12 smiter.



Yeah.

Wait what?


smites?

 

-----signature-----
"Password, you and I both know your posting style is quintessential of baiting/trolling." - Chanell
"never listen to anything Password says, he is a creature devoted to chaos and misery. " - Pentegarn
StanleyM84  1 star
Posts: 109
Registered: 2009-8-17 13:37:49
GrendelRex posted:

StanleyM84 posted:

Yes I mentioned I was debuffed, but that damage differential from a high utility toon, sorc, to a non-utility toon, thane, is obscene. Sorcs have an insane amount of toys and to be able to assit a debuff train with that type of result is impressive. I think thanes without all that utility should have a chance at similar numbers somehow. Right now its is truely impossible.



So you really can't see the problem that might arise with a chain wearing, shield carrying melee class doing the kind of ranged damage a Sorc does when a Cabby debuffs for them?



My warrior is not strong because he wears chain and has a shield. He is strong because he has 20%baseline Master of Magery, and stoicism+det. Stack some AoM and 3,400 hits and it's an un-CC able damage sponge.

Shield is a crutch after the hybrid nerf, arrow changes, block% nerf, and DW penetration. It's all but useless and thanes don't really have the points to spend in it,
Chain is a weak form of a heretic buff,

The game didn't seem to break when heretic's were introduced. 900 is not an uncommon hit from a high rank tic, oh and they got heals too! Yay.

 

-----signature-----
Gaven rr11|9 Warrior
Gavster rr10 Healer, Gavenjr rr8 sm, Gavena rr7 valk, Gaviir rr7 vamp
rr6 and under: Gavani, Gavain, Gmaul, Gavensrm
Currently playing - Anicethane - r9l5 Thane
GrendelRex  1 star
Posts: 156
Registered: 2004-2-29 09:00:36
StanleyM84 posted:

GrendelRex posted:

StanleyM84 posted:

Yes I mentioned I was debuffed, but that damage differential from a high utility toon, sorc, to a non-utility toon, thane, is obscene. Sorcs have an insane amount of toys and to be able to assit a debuff train with that type of result is impressive. I think thanes without all that utility should have a chance at similar numbers somehow. Right now its is truely impossible.



So you really can't see the problem that might arise with a chain wearing, shield carrying melee class doing the kind of ranged damage a Sorc does when a Cabby debuffs for them?



My warrior is not strong because he wears chain and has a shield. He is strong because he has 20%baseline Master of Magery, and stoicism+det. Stack some AoM and 3,400 hits and it's an un-CC able damage sponge.

Shield is a crutch after the hybrid nerf, arrow changes, block% nerf, and DW penetration. It's all but useless and thanes don't really have the points to spend in it,
Chain is a weak form of a heretic buff,

The game didn't seem to break when heretic's were introduced. 900 is not an uncommon hit from a high rank tic, oh and they got heals too! Yay.



So in other words you really can't see a potential problem with a melee class with good defense hitting harder with ranged spells than pretty much every other caster in the game? Well if you get your way I'll be back on live in a heartbeat and I know what class I'll play.

As for Tics, you really can't see the difference between insta's and spammable versus focus spells????

When did Warriors get MoM???? And why?
StanleyM84  1 star
Posts: 109
Registered: 2009-8-17 13:37:49
Tic's focus ramps up very fast. Thane cannot currently ramp up on anything, that's my point.

Either with a debuff train, or a large crit, or if mythic puts in some ramp-up, I would like to see thanes able to do the dps of a non-primary spec nuke caster considering that's what a thane is.

I don't know where I got MoM above, must have been late. I ment AoM avoidance of magic for what makes my warrior hearty. /boggle.

 

-----signature-----
Gaven rr11|9 Warrior
Gavster rr10 Healer, Gavenjr rr8 sm, Gavena rr7 valk, Gaviir rr7 vamp
rr6 and under: Gavani, Gavain, Gmaul, Gavensrm
Currently playing - Anicethane - r9l5 Thane
orrime  1 star
Title: Camelot Vault Staff
Hib Melee Mentor

Posts: 85
Registered: 2010-4-15 03:34:07
So basically, you want to deal as much as a sorc on debuffed targets with lucky crits ?

I guess even sorcs would want to do that on a regular basis.

VaultNetwork.net is an independently operated community forum and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or technically based on IGN, GameSpy, FilePlanet, GameStats, or the former IGN/GameSpy Vault Network.
References to VaultNetwork.net mean this site/domain. VNBoards-style presentation is a visual homage only. By using this site, you agree to the forum rules.