vn_lordmacabre posted:
I've got several variations on a Justicar build which avoid pretty much all the "tank" talents. I do take the flat -% damage talent, but then I play on a PvP server and intended to get that anyway.
The real problem of the Justicar isn't even with the tank talents. It's the overall lack of healing utility in the soul.
You get:
- Doctrine of Righteousness (your main heal)
- Doctrine of Bliss (when you get hurt)
- that group Doctrine, for when anyone else gets hurt
- Salvation, which has worse HPS than even the worst HoT out there. In my Druid off-spec, the (untalented) Faerie would heal for around double the amount on her HoT. And we're talking about a fully talented Salvation in Mien of Honour stance.
- Later on you will get Reprieve, which admittedly heals for a lot, but... 5 minute cooldown? Come on...
Now, if you're doing dungeons, the Justicar works just fine, if the tank receives continuous mediocre damage. You'll have a breeze healing that away, but then again, so does everyone. If the tank receives either massive burst OR continuous high damage, you will not be able to keep up with it due to the nature of Doctrines. You build up Convictions, you release Convictions to heal. But if you have to use 2 DoRs for every melee hit you get in, you'll run out of Convictions and the tank will run out of HP before you can get another Conviction up. Likewise, if the tank is hit by a huge burst, you do not have the means to quickly heal it.
Both Doctrines and Salvation healing need to be looked at for their HPS. Especially the latter. Maybe introduce a mid-tier talent to give Doctrines a chance to not use Convictions (like Blizzard did with Word of Glory)? Or bump up the transferred healing to the Righteous Mandate from Salvation by 100%. As is now, the Justicar healer needs a bit of work done to make him viable as a main healer.
Edit:
Eh, massive rant, sorry... but was really looking forward to playing a Justicar healer and was more than a bit disappointed haha
-----signature-----
WoW: DK, Priest and a ton of other alts
Waiting for Rift.