| Author |
Topic:
So it looks like Manning is probably out in Indy, where does he rate all time if he retires now? [Locked] |
Cuttlery  Title: Wanna see what you missed?
Posts: 2,631
Registered: 2001-1-9 19:31:21
|
Date Posted:
1/1/00 12:01am
Subject:
So it looks like Manning is probably out in Indy, where does he rate all time if he retires now? |
So we are in agreement then that its
1) Bart Starr
2) Aaron Rodgers
3) Lynn Dickey
etc etc etc?
-----signature-----
0.o
Bored and Useless
|
regulator_cracka Title: They finally recognized greatness.
Posts: 3,726
Registered: 2009-1-6 15:07:53
|
Date Posted:
1/1/00 12:01am
Subject:
So it looks like Manning is probably out in Indy, where does he rate all time if he retires now? |
Mangler_SC posted:
It's foolish to rate by championships alone.
I didn't. I said start with Championships and then put some type of math value to things like passing yards, touchdowns, wins, etc , some with higher values than others, and then let the math sort out the ones that are tied in rings and work down.
I think we are all in agreement that Rodgers is probably stuck holding michael vick's jockstrap for now. /agree.
-----signature-----
Self Appointed Smart Ass - Level 80
If you think my opinion is idiotic, re-read yours.
Dont worry I will give my opinion anyways.
The PvP MMO is NOT a "niche" market, Mythic is just a "niche" company.
|
-Abysmal- Posts: 1,328
Registered: 2000-12-20 06:45:24
|
Date Posted:
1/1/00 12:01am
Subject:
So it looks like Manning is probably out in Indy, where does he rate all time if he retires now? |
Cuttlery posted:
So we are in agreement then that its
1) Bart Starr
2) Aaron Rodgers
3) Lynn Dickey
etc etc etc?
sure, if you are only talking about QB's in the turnover machine!
Starr and Rodgers are the oddities.
Dickey had only 4 seasons in GB where he threw more TD's than INT's and one of them was 5-4 in a 5 game season!
-----signature-----
Now i LIVESTRONG
GO PATRIOTS
Yankees SUCK!
 I wish AC looked better, I miss it
 I love you forever Jamie
|
-Abysmal- Posts: 1,328
Registered: 2000-12-20 06:45:24
|
Date Posted:
1/1/00 12:01am
Subject:
So it looks like Manning is probably out in Indy, where does he rate all time if he retires now? |
Mangler_SC posted:
It's foolish to rate by championships alone.
pretty sure we all agree with that.
-----signature-----
Now i LIVESTRONG
GO PATRIOTS
Yankees SUCK!
I wish AC looked better, I miss it
I love you forever Jamie
|
Cuttlery Title: Wanna see what you missed?
Posts: 2,631
Registered: 2001-1-9 19:31:21
|
Date Posted:
1/1/00 12:01am
Subject:
So it looks like Manning is probably out in Indy, where does he rate all time if he retires now? |
You sure are jealous.
-----signature-----
0.o
Bored and Useless
|
regulator_cracka Title: They finally recognized greatness.
Posts: 3,726
Registered: 2009-1-6 15:07:53
|
Date Posted:
1/1/00 12:01am
Subject:
So it looks like Manning is probably out in Indy, where does he rate all time if he retires now? |
-Abysmal- posted:
Mangler_SC posted:
It's foolish to rate by championships alone.
pretty sure we all agree with that.
Yes and No, you have to start with rings. The real best win big in crunch time and that is that.
-----signature-----
Self Appointed Smart Ass - Level 80
If you think my opinion is idiotic, re-read yours.
Dont worry I will give my opinion anyways.
The PvP MMO is NOT a "niche" market, Mythic is just a "niche" company.
|
NeoKarnak  Posts: 346
Registered: 2009-12-21 18:31:34
|
Date Posted:
1/1/00 12:01am
Subject:
So it looks like Manning is probably out in Indy, where does he rate all time if he retires now? |
regulator_cracka posted:
-Abysmal- posted:
Mangler_SC posted:
It's foolish to rate by championships alone.
pretty sure we all agree with that.
Yes and No, you have to start with rings. The real best win big in crunch time and that is that.
Not in football you don't. Too many factors. Trent Dilfer is NOT a better QB than Marino or Tarkenton.
-----signature-----
When was the last time you were honest with yourself?
|
NeoKarnak Posts: 346
Registered: 2009-12-21 18:31:34
|
Date Posted:
1/1/00 12:01am
Subject:
So it looks like Manning is probably out in Indy, where does he rate all time if he retires now? |
Walker_ID posted:
if we are talking best of all time then favre definitely doesn't belong on the list and neither does rodgers....give rodgers a few more years an i'm sure he will go down as one of the best ever
my list would be
1) Montana
2) Elway
3) Marino
4) Manning
5) Brady
6) Staubach
7) Young
8) Unitas
9) Graham
10) Jim Kelly/Brees
That's a pretty good list. I would put Tarkenton at number 8, 9 or 10 though.
Rodgers will get there eventually.
Majikowski? GTFO Cutt. Stop trolling your Failpackers of yesteryear.
-----signature-----
When was the last time you were honest with yourself?
|
regulator_cracka Title: They finally recognized greatness.
Posts: 3,726
Registered: 2009-1-6 15:07:53
|
Date Posted:
1/1/00 12:01am
Subject:
So it looks like Manning is probably out in Indy, where does he rate all time if he retires now? |
NeoKarnak posted:
in football you don't. Too many factors. Trent Dilfer is NOT a better QB than Marino or Tarkenton.
you obviously do not understand football then.
-----signature-----
Self Appointed Smart Ass - Level 80
If you think my opinion is idiotic, re-read yours.
Dont worry I will give my opinion anyways.
The PvP MMO is NOT a "niche" market, Mythic is just a "niche" company.
|
Walker_ID  Posts: 673
Registered: 2002-5-29 10:20:09
|
Date Posted:
1/1/00 12:01am
Subject:
So it looks like Manning is probably out in Indy, where does he rate all time if he retires now? |
the 80's and 90's was the golden age for super QBs and football in general IMO
we have good stuff now.....but man nothing compares to the rivalries of those times.....
hell...it was the best time in sports all around....basketball and hockey and baseball
maybe it's just me....but when you talk about all time greats from each of those sports....look how many come from that time period
-----signature-----
You can't outrun Darwin
|
|
