| Author |
Topic:
So it looks like Manning is probably out in Indy, where does he rate all time if he retires now? [Locked] |
regulator_cracka  Title: They finally recognized greatness.
Posts: 3,726
Registered: 2009-1-6 15:07:53
|
Date Posted:
1/1/00 12:01am
Subject:
So it looks like Manning is probably out in Indy, where does he rate all time if he retires now? |
Surge_MT posted:
By this logic, Big Ben is in front of both of them. 3 trips, 2 wins (1 win actually was from wildcard - 2005).
And I would have to agree. Point validated!
-----signature-----
Self Appointed Smart Ass - Level 80
If you think my opinion is idiotic, re-read yours.
Dont worry I will give my opinion anyways.
The PvP MMO is NOT a "niche" market, Mythic is just a "niche" company.
|
-Abysmal- Posts: 1,328
Registered: 2000-12-20 06:45:24
|
Date Posted:
1/1/00 12:01am
Subject:
So it looks like Manning is probably out in Indy, where does he rate all time if he retires now? |
Surge_MT posted:
regulator_cracka posted:
JD_HOGG posted:
regulator_cracka posted:
You do realize if the Giants win the Superbowl that then Eli easily surpasses Rodgers on that list, right?
2 rings > 1. Not to mention Eli did it from Wildcard to Superbowl, twice. Very tough to do.
He already surpassed Rodgers...one ring plus one extra Superbowl appearance.
True, but this win would cement it!
By this logic, Big Ben is in front of both of them. 3 trips, 2 wins (1 win actually was from wildcard - 2005).
wait, are we talking superbowls or rape cases?
-----signature-----
Now i LIVESTRONG
GO PATRIOTS
Yankees SUCK!
 I wish AC looked better, I miss it
 I love you forever Jamie
|
Mangler_SC Title: Bellybutton Lint Collector
Posts: 1,856
Registered: 2003-12-2 08:37:05
|
Date Posted:
1/1/00 12:01am
Subject:
So it looks like Manning is probably out in Indy, where does he rate all time if he retires now? |
Trent Dilfer has a ring. That must put him in the top 10.
Morons.
-----signature-----
.
Mangler had an accident on the way home from the liquor store. He was run off the road and crashed into a woman's clinic. It was one giant Pabst smear.
-Bou_Te
.
Soylent CLiKK -- It's PEEEEEOPLEEE  |
regulator_cracka Title: They finally recognized greatness.
Posts: 3,726
Registered: 2009-1-6 15:07:53
|
Date Posted:
1/1/00 12:01am
Subject:
So it looks like Manning is probably out in Indy, where does he rate all time if he retires now? |
Mangler_SC posted:
Trent Dilfer has a ring. That must put him in the top 10.
Morons.
You obviously lost track of the conversation turn, we, at least I, was just saying those who come before Rodgers. And Eli would be one of them and raper. But then again I do not feel Rodgers is even in the top 15 to begin with.
*And actually Rodger's number + wins would still be >>> than Dilfer's blind luck one year.
-----signature-----
Self Appointed Smart Ass - Level 80
If you think my opinion is idiotic, re-read yours.
Dont worry I will give my opinion anyways.
The PvP MMO is NOT a "niche" market, Mythic is just a "niche" company.
|
-Abysmal- Posts: 1,328
Registered: 2000-12-20 06:45:24
|
Date Posted:
1/1/00 12:01am
Subject:
So it looks like Manning is probably out in Indy, where does he rate all time if he retires now? |
Mangler_SC posted:
Trent Dilfer has a ring. That must put him in the top 10.
Morons.
dont forget Jeff Hostetler!
-----signature-----
Now i LIVESTRONG
GO PATRIOTS
Yankees SUCK!
I wish AC looked better, I miss it
I love you forever Jamie
|
Walker_ID  Posts: 673
Registered: 2002-5-29 10:20:09
|
Date Posted:
1/1/00 12:01am
Subject:
So it looks like Manning is probably out in Indy, where does he rate all time if he retires now? |
if we are talking best of all time then favre definitely doesn't belong on the list and neither does rodgers....give rodgers a few more years an i'm sure he will go down as one of the best ever
my list would be
1) Montana
2) Elway
3) Marino
4) Manning
5) Brady
6) Staubach
7) Young
8) Unitas
9) Graham
10) Jim Kelly/Brees
-----signature-----
You can't outrun Darwin
|
Mangler_SC Title: Bellybutton Lint Collector
Posts: 1,856
Registered: 2003-12-2 08:37:05
|
Date Posted:
1/1/00 12:01am
Subject:
So it looks like Manning is probably out in Indy, where does he rate all time if he retires now? |
Based on championships alone, Bart Starr is #1.
He won 5 championships in 7 years; 1961, 1962, 1965, 1966 and 1967.
Joe Montana and Terry Bradshaw have 4 each.
-----signature-----
.
Mangler had an accident on the way home from the liquor store. He was run off the road and crashed into a woman's clinic. It was one giant Pabst smear.
-Bou_Te
.
Soylent CLiKK -- It's PEEEEEOPLEEE |
regulator_cracka Title: They finally recognized greatness.
Posts: 3,726
Registered: 2009-1-6 15:07:53
|
Date Posted:
1/1/00 12:01am
Subject:
So it looks like Manning is probably out in Indy, where does he rate all time if he retires now? |
Mangler_SC posted:
Based on championships alone, Bart Starr is #1.
He won 5 championships in 7 years; 1961, 1962, 1965, 1966 and 1967.
Joe Montana and Terry Bradshaw have 4 each.
Brady will probably have 4 after this year, right? So there would be your top 4, which order would then have to depend on stats + awards like MVPs etc etc. Some rating system would have to mathematically formulated for accuracy. *And you know Aikman has 3 so he would be close next in line.
-----signature-----
Self Appointed Smart Ass - Level 80
If you think my opinion is idiotic, re-read yours.
Dont worry I will give my opinion anyways.
The PvP MMO is NOT a "niche" market, Mythic is just a "niche" company.
|
-Abysmal- Posts: 1,328
Registered: 2000-12-20 06:45:24
|
Date Posted:
1/1/00 12:01am
Subject:
So it looks like Manning is probably out in Indy, where does he rate all time if he retires now? |
regulator_cracka posted:
Mangler_SC posted:
Based on championships alone, Bart Starr is #1.
He won 5 championships in 7 years; 1961, 1962, 1965, 1966 and 1967.
Joe Montana and Terry Bradshaw have 4 each.
Brady will probably have 4 after this year, right? So there would be your top 4, which order would then have to depend on stats + awards like MVPs etc etc. Some rating system would have to mathematically formulated for accuracy. *And you know Aikman has 3 so he would be close next in line.
that's the tough part...
and is it fair to compare and limit a 12 team 4 round championship to a 2 team 1 game championship?
-----signature-----
Now i LIVESTRONG
GO PATRIOTS
Yankees SUCK!
I wish AC looked better, I miss it
I love you forever Jamie
|
Mangler_SC Title: Bellybutton Lint Collector
Posts: 1,856
Registered: 2003-12-2 08:37:05
|
Date Posted:
1/1/00 12:01am
Subject:
So it looks like Manning is probably out in Indy, where does he rate all time if he retires now? |
It's foolish to rate by championships alone.
-----signature-----
.
Mangler had an accident on the way home from the liquor store. He was run off the road and crashed into a woman's clinic. It was one giant Pabst smear.
-Bou_Te
.
Soylent CLiKK -- It's PEEEEEOPLEEE |
|
