I win ?

"Comparing the most overpowered RA in the game to the most overpowered class seems like an invalid comparision to me (hell the Savs got nerfed last patch and none of us REALLY know for sure if they're still gods without more testing)."


I comparison doesn't even need to be made because we agree on the following statements... correct me if I'm wrong plz.


Savages = Advantage

BoF = Advantage

instant PBAE disease = Advantage

SOS = Advantage


Advantage = Advantage


I compared the recast times on my advantages with yours. 8 seconds vs. 30 minutes & permanent vs. 30 minutes. Which is a valid comparison because we already agreed that Advantage = Advantage. Now if you want to turn this into a mathematic equasion you have to quantify a number system to evaluate the advantage provided by each advantage and assign them a number. Now I can't create that system because I wouldn't know where to start, but I can prove that savages > BoF in an Advantage/Hour scenario, assuming the spell in it's full duration is given a single value and not a value per second, in the following way:


BOF = advantage (x)(2) = z/hour

SOS = advantage (y)(2) = w/hour

Savage = advantage (a)(infinity) = infinity/hour

disease = advantage (b)(450) = c/hour


Now I can use this to form some VALID conclusions based on the information I have just provided by plugging in some numbers.


If the advantage value of 2 every time it is used and we account for the 8 second recast timer we have 450 uses per hour. now we get a value of 450 advantage points per hour 450 APH


Now if we assume that SOS provides us with the same EXACT advantage over time as PBAE disease does that would give SOS an advantage time of 225 per use. So basically 225 uses of PBAE disease = 1 SOS in the APH assumption.


Now we set up this same relationship between BOF and a savage, but due to the fact that savages have no re-use timer the equation looks like this:


1. Savage advantage (x)(infinity) = infinity

2. BoF and savages are equal in advantage

1a. BoF advantage (y)(2) = infinity


Now I don't think BoF has an advantage value of infinity, but based on this arguement... which is valid... savages do.

owned.

 

-----signature-----

oh my.

lol

pretty sad when you have to go to mathmatical equations to prove an obvious fact to people who are obviously thick headed

GOOD JOB STAND

 

-----signature-----

F U all with your savage groups compared to bof/sos groups, OMG WHAT ABOUT THE HIBS? ARE WE JUST GIMP?


GP MAN GP!!

Hibs are just in the middle Phel.


Doh...

 

-----signature-----

/respect for LA +X


i was in my guild group of 8 people and we say LA and another guidl group (dunno who it was) the otehr group engaged us in 8v8 and i watched LA look at us for a sec, then go away. but of course youc am back aftyer and wtfpwned us. =P i would say we did good though againest you guys (there also might have been 1 or 2 extra people, not sure) we lasted for a good time and almsot killed eitehr xar or anty a few times but 2 helaers + shaman or whatever you guys have + ubar assist = teh win.


BTW we killed most other groups 8vs8 and 8vs16.

ardoi what happened to you is what LA excels at!!!


See if they see a fight, then leave and then wait till noobie middys are dead and then come and hit albs while medding then they can say hey we only 8 vs 8 and we dont zerg.


But in all reality they just wanted to be on super easy mode instead of easy mode. If they really cared about a good 8 vs 8 they should have left you for a good 10 min to move to apk and rebuff and move out again. I have seen release do this alot too. This is how they claim to only run 8.