Assuming Peyton was healthy, I'd go:
1a: Brady
1b: P. Manning
3: Brees
4: Rodgers
5: E. Manning
6: Rivers is sorta here, but had a strange year
E. Manning has been clutch numerous times in his career. He really has a grasp on the offense now and has some go to receivers. He is looking legitimate to me. Last year was unfortunate for him, because a crazy percentage, like 70-80%, of his picks last year were off tipped balls or receivers not fighting to break up an interception. He got a lot of bad press for that. NY is so hot and cold. One minute him and Coughlin are on the hot seat, the next they might be SB favorites. Crazy.
-----signature-----
Devaster
Shadow Syndicate [-S-]
Chesapeake - Ultima Online