First of all, I just have to say thank you Gouru, for yet again making me laugh, lol. I just love your sense of humor.
Second, while I have never really had any need for convoluted crafting macro plugins, I have used MakeIt! since it came out, and have never once found it to be confusing or hard to use, and in fact, I found it quite simple, and it did every single thing I've ever wanted to make. The maiin things I've used it for are Beer, the simple chorizite potions, and the advanced dispell potions. Occasionally I'll whip up a few wrapped arrowheads, but that is rare.
Robochef could never make the advanced dispell potions, because it lacked the ability to combine oil with oil. While you could edit the xml to add the recipes (they weren't in there by default), you still had to do the one step manually. (At least when I used it they were not there).
MakeIt! has those in the fullrecipelist.xml, and does them without a single hitch. Not once have I had it give me errors, and it can quickly make as many things as you have the components for. I've done 1000 chorizite potions in less than 30 minutes.
Now, granted, I don't do things that require you buff every hour, I don't do anything that requires you regain health or stamina or anything like that, so I have absolutely no reference for the abilities of MakeIt to do those things, and honestly I can't think of any reason why anyone would need something like this. Trade Health Elixirs are pretty obsolete on the server I play on, so *shrug*.
For me, MakeIt is awesome, simple, easy and fast, and I recommend it to anyone who asks what to use.
-----signature-----

Ling Mei - Veteran Swordswoman

Lingie - Abu's Health-Addicted Support Mage
Directionally Impaired in AC since 1999
The sun itself sees not 'till heaven clears.