I did some troubleshooting this last night with Grimbold but he is still not sure what is going on.
for some reason when I re-installed castaways again with him, it made the following folder paths
1-
My Documents/Castaway/Logs/Leafcull/Red Scourger
My Documents/Castaway/Settings/Leafcull/Red Scourger
the CastAway.dll is in the Castaway folder
2-
C:/Program Files/Castaway/Logs
the CastAway.dll is in the Castaway folder there too
so it's got him stumped as to why it is doing this.
-----signature-----
LC - Tarqon II / Pandora Valena