I think you can. At one point I had my computer set up with IIS for testing php pages with php4. When php5 was released, I installed it without uninstalling php4. I vaguely remember associating the .php4 and .php5 extensions with their respective versions of php in IIS, but it was a while ago and I didn't really know what I was doing

. I also don't remember if I had to do anything else to get it to work. I've reformatted since then and haven't set IIS up again, so I can't check... I'd definatley recommend trying it on another computer before doing it on a server.
-----signature-----
[LotRO] Digero (Guardian), Digrim (Burglar), Dignite (LM), Azrea (Hunter) - Landroval
[AC] Digero, Lyera, Draxxe - Leafcull (Retired)
[CoH] Devil's Zealot, Scinta, Izzard - Guardian (Retired)
Digero's AC Decal Plugins:
http://decal.acasylum.com